Check which way the cut sides face
The Cuisinart CPT450BPU instructions say its Bagel setting toasts one side and warms the other. The diagram shows the cut faces pointing toward each other. Use the diagram for your own toaster, since the instructions describe a particular model.
Look at the crust as well as the cut side
In a buyer discussion, a bagel fan reported that the outside still came out darker than they wanted. In a separate test of the GE G9TMA2SSPSS, the Bagel setting browned both sides. The cut side browned more, but the crust still darkened. A close-up of the cut side alone would miss that difference.
When comparing the minMAX MNS-604 toaster or another model, check that your usual bagel halves fit the slots. If keeping the crust soft matters, put models with clear loading instructions and a test showing both sides on your shortlist.








